What should be the consequence for performing an incomplete major element?

When a gymnast performs an incomplete major element, the appropriate consequence is to lose up to the value of the element. This reflects the importance of completing all required elements in a routine, as they contribute significantly to the overall score. A major element is defined as a skill that carries value and is fundamental to the routine's composition. If it is not executed in its entirety, it indicates a missed opportunity for the gymnast to showcase their skills, thus justifying a reduction in score.

Losing double the value of the element would be too severe, as it doesn't align with the established guidelines that indicate a more moderate penalty for incomplete skills. Gaining additional value is not applicable since a major element must be correctly and completely executed to earn its full value. Lastly, no penalty would undermine the scoring system and encourage incomplete performance, which is contrary to the principles of fair judging in gymnastics. Therefore, losing up to the value of the element appropriately addresses the situation while maintaining the integrity of the scoring process.